I think there is a small change that FX made that is getting overlooked by most of us. There are two general types of Impacts with Power Plenums out there... those where the PP was installed by FX (either bought new with the power plenum installed when the gun was originally manufactured at the factory, or those that were sent back to FX to have the PP upgrade installed), and those that were upgraded to the PP by the owners who just purchased the PP kit and installed it themselves.
A common opinion is that when you install the PP yourself, you need to use the original 57mm hammer spring to avoid the lower velocities that most people are reporting after installing the power plenum with the 52mm hammer spring that comes with the PP kit. This is a perfectly viable solution to the condition of running out of hammer spring tension preload at the hammer spring tension adjuster. After all, if you cannot add any more hammer spring preload tension, and the hammer is not opening valve enough to obtain the higher velocities, you have to increase the hammer striking energy another way... and the easiest way is to use the original spring which had more power when an equal amount of preload was applied by the hammer spring tension adjuster.
Using the 57mm hammer spring is one solution to the problem, but I think FX implemented another method, but it was not part of the PP kit. Generally speaking (I'm sure it's possible some of the very first ones out the door from FX may not have had the change, so I'm speaking "generally" here), the Impacts with PPs coming from FX (factory builds or FX upgrades) are coming to customers/owners with a 16mm Hammer Spring Tension Adjuster (HSTA) slider. This was changed from the original 18mm slider that pretty much all guns in the field had when the PPs started shipping for the DIY owner installed upgrades. So, if your PP was installed in the field after the PP was announced and started shipping from FX, it was installed on a gun having an 18mm HSTA slider vs the 16mm slider the FX installed PP guns were shipping with. The 16mm slider gives you an additional 2mm of HSTA preload adjustment before the HSTA maxes out, achieving a lot of what you achieve by using the 57mm hammer spring... more energy from the hammer strike.
I think this is why we are seeing a lot of people who have owner-installed PPs using the 57mm spring, or using the 52mm spring from the kit, then commenting about unexpectedly low velocities, and inability to achieve the higher velocities. If they have an 18mm slider installed, they have 2mm less HSTA preload available to them than the factory PP models have. This is why the 52mm spring is fine for the factory install versions of the PP models, and as such, is included in the PP kit. Unfortunately, the 16mm HSTA slider is not part of the PP kit, so a field install is not the same as a factory built PP model unless you change your slider to the 16mm version as well. It would be really nice if this 16mm slider was included with the PP kit. Maybe it is not, because every field upgrade already has a 57mm hammer spring available if needed.
Just my thoughts after my experience with this issue. I have field-upgraded 4 of our 5 Impacts, and I saw the same thing the OP in this thread is experiencing. I then CNC trimmed my 18mm sliders to 16mm sliders, and now have no problems achieving higher velocities if using higher regulator pressures and going into that extra 2mm of adjustment now available to me (using the 52mm kit spring).
Does this seem to make sense?