I’m glad you brought this topic up Mike, because I have often wondered what actually constitutes “hole in hole” accuracy.
There are some very good descriptions and interpretations expressed on this thread already, and I like the explanations and differences given for “same hole,” “one jagged hole,” “one big hole.” My shooting experiences equates more to these definitions and usually at only 20 yards when I’m trying to get my 20 yard zero for back yard pesting or plinking purposes. Even then, if I am being honest, the one hole may be pretty close to the first pellet’s diameter but it really is same hole, jagged hole, or one bigger hole.
Literally speaking, I also agree with those that define “hole in hole,” as several or many shots go through the same “first pellet’s hole diameter.” That said, I kind of chuckle when I see forum members who describe a particular shooting session as “hole in hole” at 50, 75 or 100 yards. I like Frank’s analogy with the facial expression from “the Rock.” I laugh because my kids have always said, “ Dad, you are a real doubting Thomas.” I can relate!
Think about it truthfully, how many people have actually shot one pellet hole’s diameter at 100 yards for a five shot ( or more) group? I think this might be one of those discussions where people interpret the terminology differently.
So, my takeaway is that I have a much improved perspective on this topic.