Texan 357 ss or bulldog

Factory stock, unmodified, untweaked... my money is on the Texan for both FPE and Accuracy. My bulldog (from the factory), was good to about 1 minute of deer heart at 100 yards (less than a 4 inch circle). It was just short of 200 FPE with the 145 Grain Nosler Extreme slug. It gives me about 4 shots before drop becomes notable. 

Those who have modified their Bulldogs are getting some great results with enhanced porting/valve/larger air tube/regulator.... but that is an additional investment.

In the end, the rotary mag was important to me.