Did you use the FX parts diagram to get the sizes from? If so, FX uses the inner diameter as the first number and the o ring cross section thickness(or just call it o ring thickness) as the second number. At least FX does on the Wildcat.
I shop for O rings exclusively from oringsandmore.com also, and the way they call out the sizes matches up with how FX does it- 1st number inner diameter and second number the thickness. Where do you think you went wrong?
Anytime someone gives me o ring sizes(wether a fellow forum member or even a vendor of o rings), the most important thing I need clarified is if the first number called out is either the inner diameter or the outer diameter.