Moderator for .30 impact?

Neil Clague made mine. It's totally silent - hammer slap and target ring is the loudest part of firing it. And awesome looking. I might even be interested in selling it as he is making me a one piece shroud/LDC for it now. It's finished and ought to be here next week. If all goes according to plan I may be interested in selling the original LDC he made me. Very pretty piece. Here's a pic of the gun.



1582304458_3901208195e500ccabd9d17.30123338_Impact.jpg

 
Are you looking for the correct answer or someone to agree with you?

Please forgive me, but this post begs the question.....

You called the manufacturer for a recommendation about his products.

He recommended one item over the other and gave an acceptable reason as to why.

And because there has been no review of the recommended item you are questioning his recommendation over the one you had your heart set on?

Who better to know his own products than the guy who makes them?

I have no allegiance to Donnie. I do not own nor have I ever have owned one of his moderators. Nothing against his products. A bunch of guys that do, swear by them. Even FX Airguns selected his moderators to install and ship on their guns to US distributors. If that's not a shout out to the performance and quality of Donnie's moderators I don't know what is.....

Personally, I only have Neil's moderators. I've not owed a .30 Impact however I have owned a Evanix .30 with one of Neil's moderators and it made it very quiet. FWIW, it clocked 44 grains at 875fps. 

Can't say I've ever put my DB meter on a mouse when it farted but I digress. 

Good luck with your decision..... 


 
I’ve been reading here for days now, but can’t find the correct answer. 

I need to quiet one of my impacts mkII .30/700mm as much as possible. I looked on youtube, and did see impact owners putting the DonnyFL Emperor on their 700mm barrel. And surely, that monster quets it down big time! 

But i asked Donny himself for advice. I had 2 models in my head: the Emperor or the Shogun. He Instantly told me NEVER to use the Emperor on my impact gue to the weight of that thing. He recommended the .30 Shogun. All good, but it looks like nobody every bought a Shogun! No reviews, or videos to find on the Shogun. And before i spend $220 ( european price) i would like to hear how quiet it makes the .30.

And i have no experience what so ever with other brands. A bummer that the Emperor is so heavy…

if someone might have a shogun & video…………i would appreciate ANY advice overhere. 

Thx. Rudder

You can use the emperor, but you will need to make a barrel band to support the barrel



I am using the emperor plus extension on my DREAMLINE, and a barrel band is a must


 
thx for all the answers…except one! READ before you comment please! 

I got NO CLUE how other brands perform, and on every single article the name DonnyFL shows up! 

I was looking for a good brand, and if possible, with review video! 
BUT: @ JSB18 : you got the Shogun on the impact. Did you EVER noticed any plinking inside the Shogun?

It I TOTALLY on the contrary that i had my mind set on DonnyFL! Why? Because a few months ago i asked him advice for my previous .25 impact! His advice : if you buy the Shogun for a .25 FX impact, PLEASE choose the .30 caliber !!! Still got the mail! Why? Because of the length of the Shogun, AND the way how FX barrels are supported, made, that he received many complaints about the pellets plinking inside the long Shogun!! These are NOT my words! 

And THAT is why i hold back to buy the Shogun, because .30 is the biggest size available. 


AND @cowabunika : SPOT ON!! I also got THAT answer from Donny himself. I i WOULD go for the Emperor, i would need to use a “barrel band” on the impact, to support the weight of the Emperor +maybe the extension. 

For one : I’m TOTALLY honest about this and i have NO CLUE what a barrel band is, or even better, HOW and where can it be bought or “mounted”??



and i ALSO asked if someone could recommend me another brand. I never said anything about money . Titanium i VERY lighter compared to aluminium! So why shouldn’t there be a titanium moderator out there, the gives the same result as an Emperor but @half the weight. 


and last: why, in gods name, if you are new to this forum, there will ALWAYS be a “pro” criticizing my questions and asking for help? 
I will now look what a barrel strap is……

thx & enjoy the weekend you all.

a barrel band is just something that supports the barrel
I made mine with some PVC pipes, some 1mm washers, and some epoxy to glue them all together

e.g. https://ohioairgun.com/products/fx-crown-barrel-band

As you can imagine, the FX guns only have a single point of support for the barrel, at the very back
So it is very easy for the barrel to move, especially when there is a heavy weight at the muzzle

I started with a SUMO on my dream tac compact, But because of the short 380mm barrel, the SUMO was not quiet enough.
I need something that i can comfortably toy with in my backyard without upsetting neighbors
So i settled with emperor + extension, which is crazy quiet: i only hear the action of the hammer and gas hissing within the internal of the action, but nothing from the end of the barrel

to be honest, the extension is not needed, the emperor itself is plenty quiet. You can see on donny's website that the emperor is significantly heavier than his other suppressors. That is because, instead of using dampening wool, the emperor have actual aluminium (i think) internal chambers just like those used for firearms, so there is alot more metal and so much heavier