MARYLAND Needs Your Input

Chip

Member
Mar 30, 2015
151
9
GA
Today Maryland released the final proposed regulations that will allow airguns to be used on whitetail deer and bear in that state. There is a final public comment period that closes October 17 and Crosman Corporation is asking all interested airgunners to participate, even if you do not live in the state or have plans to hunt in Maryland. The state of Maryland is a leader for the eastern seaboard and many states, particularly in the northeast, will follow their lead. It is imperative your voice is heard. 

THE PROPOSALS

BULLETS & BALLS
.40 caliber AND 400 foot-pounds minimum 

ARROWS
18" minimum arrow length 
300 FPS minimum speed 

Airguns/Airbows will be allowed during muzzleloader and urban deer seasons (urban is currently shotgun, muzzleloader & archery only) 

View the full language here (they start on page 1074): 
http://www.dsd.state.md.us/MDR/4319.PDF
------------------------- 
BACKGROUND:

I've been meeting with MD DNR officials since the spring, initially about the airbow. They intended to add airbows to the crossbow season before realizing in 2016 crossbow would be rolled into the general archery season. Wanting to avoide dealing with grassroots bowhunting groups, MD DNR opted to allow airbows into the seasons mentioned above and at the same time, legalize airguns for big game. 

The first public comment period was in August. Crosman submitted a letter of support recommending a .35 caliber / 175 fpe minimum for airguns. This is in line with other states that allow airguns for big game with the exception of Missouri, which went the route Maryland is going by attempting to equate airguns with muzzleloaders. 

ACTION REQUESTED:

Express your support for allowing airguns and airbows to be allowed in Maryland for large game and politely request airgun minimums to be changed to realistically reflect their capability and request airbows be allowed during archery. 

Feel free to use or alter this suggested language: 

Dear Mr. Jayne and Secretary of Natural Resources, 

Thank you for your thoughtful consideration of airguns and airbows and proposing their legal use for hunting whitetail deer and bear in the state of Maryland. As an airgun enthusiast with many years of experience in their use and application, I don’t believe the requirements of a minimum .40 caliber and 400 foot-pounds of energy are realistic. My experience leads me to recommend a minimum .357 caliber and 200 foot-pounds because airguns have more in common with archery in regard to effective range yet the proposed regulations appear to equate them with muzzleloaders. Air rifles are low range weapons with an effective range on whitetail deer generally well within 75 yards. Common muzzleloaders are accurate out to 150 yards and as far as 300 as with the Remington Model 700®. 

Airbows, despite their pneumatic powerplant, have more in common with archery tackle and enable lifelong bowhunters to continue the sport well beyond their ability to draw a compound, recurve or crossbow. Just as bowhunters balked at compound bow technology when recurves were popular, and later had the same reaction when crossbows gained wide appeal, the fact remains it is the same projectile and broadhead being used in airbows as with any other archery product. Therefore I respectfully request airbows be a legal alternative to crossbows for all seasons in which crossbows are eligible. 



Send your comment to Peter Jayne, Associate Director, Wildlife and Heritage Service, Department of Natural Resources, P.O. Box 68, Wye Mills, MD 21679, or call 410-827-8612, or email to [email protected] or fax to 401-827-5186. Deadline to comment is October 17.
 
Thank you, Chip. I'm quite certain now I was confusing you with another airgunnner of some renown, Jim Chapman. Your advice is well taken. Unfortunately, while there seems to be good number of Airgun enthusiasts here in the Hoosier state, I have yet to run into anyone who is but a casual pester at best. I'm unsure a single voice no matter how vocal will be sufficient. 

Thanks again, 

Rock 
 
Just from a practice point of view, .40 is not a common caliber for air rifles. It really puts the limit at 45 caliber in most cases as that is the smallest popular caliber that meets that requirement.

The minimum fpe pretty much excludes all air guns except the extreme big bores unless helium is used. 

It might be helpful if you present something more scientific than opinions on this topic. Is there any studies that show how much energy is actually needed to penetrate a deer or bear's kill zone? Perhaps something using ballistic gelatin to show the level of penetration. 

Maybe suggesting a maximum range might be a good way to propose the compromise. I.e. If the hunt was limited to 100 yards, you could show the residual energy compared to the muzzle loader at 200 yards. 

On air bows, my understanding was that they were typically more powerful than most regular cross bows and in some cases air bows are too powerful and cause arrows to overpenetrate (so they can't be removed without breaking). Tom Gaylord wrote a long article on his blog about them. 



 
Chip, 
I copy, pasted the letter you have posted and emailed it to peter. 
It's pretty cool that he took the time to write back. It was just a quick note but, he included my name in it which could mean that it wasn't just an automated response. 

AGN members - Today is the last day to help with this. Do your part! Help educate those in charge about our sport and the capabilities of modern air powered weapons for hunting purposes. 

Tom
 
Just FYI on crossbows. I have hunted with a crossbow for several years now and have taken several deer. In every instance the arrow has passed completely through the deer and stuck in a tree or the ground. The speed on my crossbow was 330+ fps when I first got it and shot it through my chrony. I have only taken one deer at a range greater than 30 yards which I consider to be a safe limit that does not give the deer enough time to react to the sound and jump the string. I shot one at 45 yards and it did not jump the string but I believe it could have if it was in an alert and ready to bolt posture.