is the exposed Fx Impact Bottle a concern?

bokes

Member
Apr 26, 2015
62
0
CA
Hi I'm trying to decide between a .25 Fx Impact or Wildcat. What I like most about the Impact is the higher shot capacity, & ability to swap bottles on the go. I wouldn't swap calibers or use any of the adjustments, I already have a power adjuster on my other .22 rifle.

My only concern is the long term effects of holding up the rifle by the bottle. I keep thinking about the physics of putting a sideways force on a long, narrow object- if the length of the bottle might create leverage to create a crack around the neck. But I admit I don't know exactly how much lateral stress these bottles can put up with. (ps. yes I'm aware I can hold up the rifle by a mounted bipod, but I don't want to depend on this.)
So is this a concern or is this all in my head?
 
I use to mess with high end paintball guns almost 10 years ago. Back then (and still today) they were powered on 4500psi carbon wrapped tanks pretty much exactly the same as what you see used on the FX Impact, Crown, etc. We were using 68 cubic inch carbon wrapped tanks which in the airgun world, is a very large and bulky tank. Here is a picture I found through Google search just to show you what that looks like. Notice that the air tank is only affixed to the paintball gun via the threads on the tank's valve. In play, these paintball guns can see a LOT of abuse as you're running & diving around, and it's usually the air tank that smacks the ground first. I use to be involved with R&D in the paintball industry, and I would say it was very rare for these tanks to fail at the neck under normal usage and reasonable amounts of abuse. The paintball industry standard of mounting tanks to the bottom of the pistol grip is a much worse design when you compare it to how airgun manufactures approach it. In general, people who use these paintball guns will on average put their equipment through much worse than what we do on our worst days as airgunners.

My opinion is that you don't need to worry about abnormal wear by holding the FX Impact by the bottle.