Help…..HW97K or AA TX200 MKIII..it's driving me crazy!

Forums Springers, Pumpers, C02, & Vintage Help…..HW97K or AA TX200 MKIII..it's driving me crazy!

  • Views : 1043
  • Link

    TiredRooster
    Participant
    Member

    I'm pretty much dead set on getting another springer shortly after Christmas. I started out trying to decide between an HW80 or HW95. Well, while I still like the HW95 I pretty much have eliminated the 80 from my list. But what has moved up to the top of my list and is keeping me up at night is trying to decide between the HW97K and the AA TX200 MKIII. I literally do nothing but think about these two rifles. I have read EVERY review and watched every video on these two that I can find. And then watch them over! I feel like a kid looking through the Sears Roebuck catalog before Christmas……I just dated myself! I have come to the conclusion that I can't go wrong with either. Both are fine and high quality springers with huge followings. But I would like to hear feed back from some of you fellas. Any opinions are welcome, but particularly from any of you that have experience with either or both and what you may think are pros/cons in a comparison. If there are any with these two. I'm very open minded and welcome your opinions please.

    Thanks

    TR

    Link

    Coldair
    Participant
    Member

    I had shot both and still have the HW97K twangy and buzzy and all and prefered it and sold the TX.

    Just so you know, they are heavy guns. What you have now is already a great gun and neither of these

    are necessarily going to give you more accuracy and are close the the power level you already have.

    The last quality springer rifle I bought was a Walther LGV Competition Ultra and I like it better than

    the TX and my HW97K and it is really incredibly quiet too.

    CA

    Link

    Richardo
    Participant
    Member

    In my younger days I owned and shot both. Yes, they are nice guns  and in my opinion both a worthy of a place in any gun cabinet. At the end of the day it comes down to personal preference as to which to own as both have their pros and cons. 

    All the best in your final decision. In my opinion you can’t go wrong with either gun. Richardo.

    Link

    socaloldman
    Participant
    Member

    Trooster,  CA and Ricardo are both on the money.  Had both, the TX is  beauty and so smooth while the HW is a superb gun.   I frankly could never pick one over the other, both quality with little differences in handling.  So quit punishing yourself and buy them both.   Some real used bargain can be had and they are almost always 99% or better.    keep us posted.

    Link

    Brazos
    Participant
    Member

    I have a TX and it's very nice with no complaints.  With the price of the 97 from Krale (currently around $360) I would buy the 97.  

    Link

    Springrrrr
    Participant
    Member

    I have them both.  The 97 was tuned by Motorhead and the TX was tuned by me at home.

    The TX is easier to work on if you want to do anything yourself.

    Both guns prefer shooting in the 12 FPE range in 177.  If you try to push them, they can become snappy and loose accuracy.

    On any given day, they are equally as accurate and enjoyable to shoot.

    If I had to choose between one or the other, I couldn't, so they are both keepers.

    Link

    spysir
    Participant
    Member

    TX is THE easiest springier ever to work on if needed.  Just a thought.

     

    John

    Link

    crittahitta
    Participant
    Member

    I have the tx200 and love it. My friend has the 97 and he loves it. I would say the biggest difference between the two is that the tx may have a edge in the beauty department. The bluing and wood is awesome. You truly cannot go wrong either way. Get one and stop killing yourself over it.

    Link

    EMrider
    Participant
    Member

    The TX is better eye candy IMHO, but in terms of build quality and accuracy, they are quite similar.

    I bought my .177 hw97k from Krale and have shot it more than any of my other springers for the past year and a half.  My hw97k is PCP-like accurate out to 30 yards, and no question the hw97k from Krale is an incredible value.

    All of my full size springers have given me optimal accuracy and shot cycle at about 12fpe.

    Good luch choosing.

    R

    Link

    rwsmike
    Participant
    Member

    I would buy whichever is cheaper and I think the hw will be 

    Link

    Jonnes
    Participant
    Member

    Go for the TX200 HC, I own one for ages now with a walnut stock in .22 and it's by far the most fun and gorgeous springer ever IMHO. I can shoot sub MOA groups at 55 yards all day with it. The trigger is better than the Rekord trigger in the HW's, the blueing and finish on the rifle is just awesome, and it just something you want to hold all day. The HW97 is fun if you're someone who likes to tune rifles, but if you want something that shoots out of the box like a tuned rifle, honestly… go TX200!

    And yes, I've owned a couple of HW97/s and 77's, and they all left my collection My TX200 on the other hand… I'm going to take that thing with me to Walhalla. 

    Let's be honest, would you say no to something as beautiful as this?

    Link

    intenseaty22
    Participant
    Member

    Hi Jonnes. That is a very clean looking moderator on that TX. What model/size Huggett is that and adapter needed? Thanks!

    Link

    Jonnes
    Participant
    Member

    It's a Huggett Belita Silencer 1/2 UNF male for .25 caliber. The .22 caliber version resulted in inaccuracy. Makes the thing super quiet.

    Link

    intenseaty22
    Participant
    Member

    Back when I started looking at quality Springers I asked the same question, but then I got into PCPs and sorta forgot about the Springers. Until I started hearing about the Walther LGV & got one. Great option btw in case you have not looked into them. Now I’m hooked. 

    I have 2 LGVs, an HW30, and looking to add both of your contenders, and perhaps an HW50 as well. 

    Good luck deciding, or better yet, get both if possible. 

    Link

    r1lover
    Participant
    Member

    A couple of folks above have given you the answer….KRALE!  You'll need some stuff to go with that new gun, and the money you can save on the HW97 will go a long ways towards a new scope and mount.  When no one can agree on which gun is better and you can save a few hundred bucks on one over the other, the answer seems pretty clear.

    If money is not a concern, buy both, you'll sleep better at night!  Or, buy two beach stocked 97's (.177 and .22) from Krale for not a whole lot more than a walnut TX will cost you from someplace else.

    Good luck.

    Link

    Samuel
    Participant
    Member

    Yep, tough call. Two of the greatest springers ever made. Interested to know why you chose to completely discount the HW80 though?

    I fully identify with having this stuff completely consume your thoughts! Glad I’m not the only one. Whichever way you go, I’m certain you’ll be delighted with the result.

    Link

    Cizur
    Participant
    Member

    I own an HW97KT with the beech stock.   I personally wouldn’t trade it for any other springer.   To me the rifle looks better than any other “top end” springer.  And the reckord trigger is…  absolute bliss. 

    But I’m biased…  all my rifles are Weihrauch. And for good reason.

    Link

    gonzav71
    Participant
    Member

    I own a 97k. I do not own A TX. I think the TX has the better stock, trigger and easier to disassemble. It costs more. HW from Krale is the best deal you can get for 97k or any other HW rifles. I will buy a TX 200 sometime next year.

    Link

    Cizur
    Participant
    Member

    I don’t understand the “easier to dissassemble” comments.  The 97 is extremely simple to take apart, clean, grease and rebuild.

    Link

    gonzav71
    Participant
    Member

    You don’t have to use a hammer to disassemble a TX.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 43 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.