Ever since i upgraded from .177 to .25, I have been trying to find a decently quiet backstop material. I think I found a good one - though this probably is not new to many of you.
I found a type of modeling clay that never hardens, never dries out, and basically stays good forever. It is a type of clay called Plastilina, and the brand I bought was a Van Aken 5 pound block of solid white, from a hobby / craft supply store. Cost me $15 for 5 lbs, but it quietly stops a 35FPE .25 polymag in under three inches.
It melts at 150F, so I put it in a tupperware container and boiled it in a large pot. It melted down and conformed to the container.
I never could find any duct putty at any of my hardware stores, but this clay is good stuff, and I poured a resin mold of a polymag
My iphone is stupid, I give up trying to place these pictures right