MM,
I wouldn't hesitate to get another Athlon. The only things I don't like about it (maybe it's just mine) is how stiff the magnification ring is. And the eyepiece focus ring rotates too easily.
Some minor things I noticed right away comparing the two:
1. The Hawke turrets are huge when compared to the Athlon, but I knew this going into the Hawke.
2. The Hawke elevation turret doesn't have marks to tell you how many turns out or in you've gone if you dial.
3. The Hawke is heavier.
4. The Hawke's reticle is nice, but it doesn't have numbers like the Athlon, and the lines are thicker on the inner part of the reticle.
If I had to give up one of them, it would be hard to say right now. I've only been out with the Hawke one time....I would need more time with it before I could make a
decision like that.