I keep reading about Donny FL moderators. Can someone please explain what the claim to fame is all about?
Are they quieter than other brands? Less expensive than other brands? What is it?
His claim to fame? ~ He was just a regular guy who was active on different airgun forums with the same passion that we all share. He started experimenting with different materials and making his own moderators for personal use. Forum members started reaching out to him to purchase his moderators because they were effective.
Are they quieter than other brands? ~ I only have experience with one of Neil Clague's LDC's and several of DonnyFL's moderators. I can't speak for the rest (Hugget, Rocker1, Trident, Roy Katsan LDC). The Neil Clague LDC I have is one of his standard models for .22cal which is 1.17"×8" with satin finished aluminum front and rear end caps that are epoxied to the carbon fiber sleeve.
There is no way to take it apart to perform maintenance without risking damage to the LDC because of the epoxy. Neil also offers the same model but in all aluminum which I believe is black powder coated. Sound reduction is very effective with Neil's LDC. I would compare it with Donny's Sumo and Koi.
Neil Clague LDC:
DonnyFL
From left to right; Fatboy, Tanto, Sumo, and Koi:
Less expensive than other brands? ~ I paid $120 for Neil's LDC not including PayPal fee. Neil does mostly custom shrouds and moderators and price may vary. You can look up Donny's Moderators on his website for pricing. I believe Huggets are $200 and up.
What is it? ~ With DonnyFL, it's multiple factors that ticks all the boxes in why I support him. His website is easy to navigate, shows IN STOCK items, and is easy to order from instead of using PayPal. His customer service is top notch. Donny will answer your questions in a timely matter.
He sometimes throws in free items in your order even if you didn't ask him to or if you were willing to pay for it. Fast shipping. Donny gets em' out quick. Neil took almost 3 weeks to get my order in but I knew that when I first placed my order. Ease of maintenance. You can take apart Donny's moderators and try different sound absorbing materials.
I have some 1 inch and .5 inch High Density Foam sheets coming in from Amazon to experiment with. Donny is constantly coming up with new designs and updates the mass via Instagram, Facebook, and his website of course. The fit and finish on Donny's moderators are top notch. Aesthetics are pleasing to the eyes as well.
Donny offers multiple adapters with different thread patterns on his site. I was almost overwhelmed when I saw them but at least it's there for you to choose from. He can also do custom adapters at your request.
I know Neil has a lot of custom shrouds/LDC designs that he has done but I don't get to see them unless someone post them in one of the forums. Neil was a little kind of brash when I was communicating with him via email. It's okay, I'm thick skinned.
Just for everyone's info, this is not a Neil Clague bashing reply. I would still order from him because I believe his products are effective. This is just my experience with two companies I've had a chance to deal with.
Jude