Cj_86,
This is slightly off subject, airgun not pump, but still O-Ring lube. Ernest Rowe recommends Super Lube multi-purpose synthetic greese in the FX Master Class series on PCP maintenance and repair. Other options might be better.... Super Lube 93003 O-Ring Silicone Greese, Scuba Diving Silicone o-ring greese, or silicone dielectric greese. Hand pumps generate high temperatures, like any compressor, and that is probably the difference. I used dielectric greese or silcone brake caliper greese when rebuilding my Benjamin hand pump
Ernest uses Pink 3M Wetordry Polishing Paper to ease sharp edges of o-ring grooves. Pink is 4000 grit, not 400 grit. 400 grit polishing paper would be green. An honest error.....he has forgotten more than I’ll ever learn about airguns......Ernest is the man!