Don't feel bad never know how you will like something if you don't try it if I had seen it at Walmart today I would've bought it anyways lol so I would've ended up with it somehow another. I've been looking at some PCP guns what are some good beginner guns
To be honest, I can't make a recommendation. It depends on the intended use and so many other things that are subjective. All I do is pest in my backyard, so I don't need a lot of power. I have 3 (not working) Nova Freedoms (two in .177 and one in .22). I liked the fact that they had the pump built in, until the pumps failed then the poppets failed. Up until that (
and these were known problems I mostly ignored when I purchased them) they were tack drivers! Well the .177s were. (
I could never get the .22 to work well, but that is another story...) I also liked the ability to switch from ~20fpe to ~13fpe with the simple turn of a knob on the .177s.
When those all experienced the said problems (I may turn them into bottle guns one day) I got a really good deal on a Benjamin Fortitude Gen2 in .177 @~$234 shipped. That deal is no longer available and I don't know that I would recommend the Fortitude for most people, especially now that Crosman has raised the price.
It has it warts, but I have "fixed" the problems enough for me.
I also have a
.177 DAR Gen2, but it shoots with more power than I want/need and I haven't yet voided my warranty by tearing into it to adjust the regulator so I can bring the FPE down to ~12fpe or less.
There is a reason why they call getting into PCPs "the rabbit hole" or "the dark side". (smile)
Shoot what you have for a while and do a LOT of research before you make your next airgun purchase. Decide what you really want/need one for and then you MAY be able to determine which one is best for you.
Believe me, I got just about the same type of answers when I first started and the advice still holds true.
For me, I need a very quiet, ~12fpe or less, accurate (from 10 to 40 yards for the most part), easy to shoot .177 for pesting in my backyard in a residential area.
So far, the Fortitude is filling that need. If I can reduce the power of the DAR, it should also do the job nicely, if it is accurate at the lower power.
Hope that helps... (smile)
P.S.
Oops, I forgot to mention that price is definitely an object for me as well. I don't have the funds that some folks seem to have.
I still don't own a compressor, but I do have 2 Chinese hand pumps that work very well for what I do.
Oh, and one other thing... buy a decent scope. Cheap scopes will always keep you guessing. It is not uncommon for people to spend at least as much on the scope as they did on the gun and more times than not the glass costs multiples of the cost of the gun. Yes, there is a reason for that. Trust me.