Chasing the best pellet for each gun?

Sometimes it gets a little comical how many of us chase the perfect pellet for each gun. I'm organizing some of the different weights and head sizes and brands that I have used over the last year. For me its usually JSB brand but of course there are so many different weights for each caliber. And I do test H&N some since they have head sizes that I like to reduce to the size my guns like. Decided to share the mess I'm working on today.

Z1t7t9O.jpg
 
Same here re: JSB & H&N, though a much more modest & limited selection ;). Nice scale! The 12" LW barrel in my Talon SS will stack unsorted 18.13gr JSB Jumbo Heavy Diablos all day long in one ragged hole to cloverleafs at 25-35yrds with an occasional flyer usually attributed to a bad skirt. I just found through experimentation that the H&N Barracuda Hunter Extremes group just as well with same POI, but with a bit more smack-down. Despite their advertised weight of 19.09gr, they come in a little light ~18.8grs and their skirts seem a little more uniform and less fragile than the JSBs. I think my search is done for now, but would have never known without testing a variety..

 
JSB seems to be my Go To pellet as well. I see you have the TBT pellet sizers with your stash of pellets Goodtogo. I have a couple as well.
The 4.53 works great for me when I'm sizing the JSB 13.4 gr Monsters for the Thomas.
I checked one tin with my pellet gauge and most of the pellets were 4.54 with none larger than 4.55 or smaller than 4.53. I thought a plus or minus 0.1 head size for the tin was pretty darn tight tolerance. Also the pellet weight for the tin was within plus or minus 0.2 grains which was tighter than any other batch of pellets I took the time to check.
I pull straight from the tin , inspect and then size it with the pellet sizer as I shoot!

 
In preparation for a filed target match tomorrow, I have opened a new tin of JSB Exact Heavy 10.34 grain (.177 cal). These are nominally 4.52, and were purchased more than a year ago from Pyramyd Air, but previously unopened. 

The protocol I recommend is to sample 10% of the tin, and thus I will gage 50 from this tin using the Pelletgage

This is what the tin looked like - there was no marking of head size, but it appears that JSB only produces this pellet in a nominal 4.52 mm size.
https://goo.gl/photos/YtGQGQZGzwBBe72C6
https://goo.gl/photos/gXfTBogbPTBZeJxKA

This JSB pellet has been my "go-to" for about two years worth of shooting. Usually, I go through some inspection when I open a tin, and once I have the sample result, I decide whether to use them. Even considering practice, a 500 piece tin will usually last me several months. 

Of the 50, gaging resulted in 8 of 4.51, 41 of 4.52, and one at 4.53 mm. I consider this a good result. The mean was 4.529 and the sample standard deviation was 0.0040 mm. Statistically, this would mean that if we have a normal distribution, 95% of the tin would be within 4.529 +/- 0.008. This is the histogram.
https://goo.gl/photos/ZUviTQBuVsEaGT6E9

There were three pellets with skirts that were dinged, I did not include them in the sample.

One may say that this does not appear to be a normal distribution (i.e. skewed, perhaps affected by screening, etc.) - nevertheless, I consider this tin to be very much usable, and I know from experience my Marauder (with Lothar Walther barrel) will do well with a 4.53 pellet - so this is practically as good as I hope to see as an inspection result. I have historically seen exactly one tin of this pellet where essentially all were gaged at 4.53 mm.

This also meets my basic quasi-statistical sampling plan - find the sample mean, and accept if no pellet is more than 0.01 mm from that mean.

For my field target match, I will screen more pellets to get 100 or so that will all be 4.53 mm. To be specific about the gaging, they will all be <4.53 and >4.52 mm. 

I recommend this process for assuring that you have the pellet your gun "likes" best, and for minimizing the chances of a flyer. I also recommend this pellet as being very consistent and stable out to about 50 yds, with 19 FPE at the muzzle.

 
  • Like
Reactions: RockBall
PG, good luck at the shoot. Thanks for info on how you use your great gauge to finding the mean. Will be ordering one shortly. I have not been into the airgun shooting discipline very long. I did read all about trying different pellets to see what your gun liked. We do similar with our bp competition rifles and pistols. My first air rifle is a .22 for hunting. While trying different pellets, I noticed that one type would shoot accurately for several shots then be off again and this happened with every type and different manufacturer I tried. Now several new airguns later, I am setting up an underlever for FT and the testing starts again. So I now have started weighing pellets and soon as I get my pelletgage I will be sizing to find the pellet my underlever likes, then I will get my tbt die to size them all. What I have got too thinking about and I am going to be testing this theory soon, maybe its not so much the particular manufacturers pellet your rifle likes, might it be a certain weight and size ? Meaning, I could sort 3 different manufacturers domed pellets to my standards and will they all group same ? I am currently in process of weighing 2500 .177 pellets using a tolerance of +- 0.10 gns. It has surprised me at how many I have found that don't even come close to my standard mean and these are all the supposedly better name brands and types. One tin of 500 had just over 60% that were well out of my weight standard, I havnt even sized the good ones yet. I am reading and seeing the same thing when it comes to head sizes not being even close to what is marked on tin. I have to wonder has it always been this way or like so many other things, the qc is not even done anymore. I have read comments where its said "there just pellets and there inexpensive" BS ! If the manufacturer is stating that their product is a certain size and weight then we as consumers should be able to count on that product at least being close to what is being claimed by them. For those of us who are shooting bench/FT or any other competition we need our pellets to be consistent in these parameters. I know several readers will think "dang this guy is being very anal and picky" YUP :) .... Think about it, most who are shooting FT are using pellets in the 8-10 gn class. So if a 10 gn pellet is off by 0.50 gn then I would think that POI at 30 yds and up would change enough to score a miss. Am I totally off on this ? I would be interested to read what parameters others have set for their FT pellets.
 
"Pelletgage"... nevertheless, I consider this tin to be very much usable, and I know from experience my Marauder (with Lothar Walther barrel) will do well with a 4.53 pellet - so this is practically as good as I hope to see as an inspection result.


Pelletgage,

What do you do with the tins that you determine are NOT usable?

By the way, I own a .22 and .25 cal Pelletgage, and am very happy I bought them.
 
I got my .177 pelletgage today and I just ordered yesterday am, tks Jerry it works great. I have already sized a couple hundred pellets. Amazing the variation in one tin. So far a H&N tin of ftt 4.50mm, have sized mostly 4.52/4.53 and some 4.54. AJ one of the THAGC and AGN members hooked me up with a like new tuned XS46U. One of those deals you just dont pass :) I added a UTG 3-12x46 w/60mm sidewheel, figured that would be a good starter setup for me just getting into FT. I want to try out different styles of springers eventually. I have a .22 break barrel that shoots good, need a PelletGage in .22 now, see if I can make that good a great.