Oldsparky, I have just completed your present journey. I moved from a Streamline and BSA Buccaneer to a Brocock Bantam and a Cricket mini. I am an old fart and not nearly as strong as before. I don't like weight and long rifles because I primarily hunt and shoot one match per month. The Bantam is a.177 I use at the match and the Cricket mini .22 is everything else. I have tried a Vulcan, a wildcat, a Taipan veteran, a Pulsar and a Daystate Renegade, an Edgun R5M , a Bantam and a Cricket. Here is my read on all of them.
First is my criterea ... no longer than a carbine, about 33", sweet to handle, i.e. does it feel comfy and fit nice, is it balanced with a scope installed, finally not too heavy to pack for 4 hours hunting, nice easy handling magazines
To heavy EDgun, Taipan, Vulcan, but the quality was stellar. solid well thought out and great workmanship.
Did not fit me well: Edgun, Taipan, Pulsar and Renegade . Again they are all great shooters and quality but just cannot get a natural feel pulling down on a rat or squirrel.
Checked all the boxes: Bantam, Wildcat and Mini Cricket.... I took the Bantam over the wildcat because of .177 and huge air tank and great Daystate quality
The Cricket just spoke to me. Came up and instantly on target, great magazines, quality almost as good as the Vulcan, lighter weight, great looking. Perhaps if I get a .25 it will be time for the WC to move in.
As a side note this sounds petty but hells bells the Renegade and Pulsar just looked kind funky and turned me off. Don't ever tell my wife I got picky about how the gun looks, my ego can't handle the ridicule. Enjoy and keep us informed.