I bought the Ruger Impact Max .22 and it is not very accurate. Open sights was more accurate than the scope that came with it. It shoots wild shots 1 out of 3 with the scope.
1" groups at 10yds with open sights.
2 1/2" groups at 15yds with the scope. Shot 50+ shots from a bench-rest and I'm convinced it isn't me but the scope and/or rifle.
Should I simply get a different scope?
Should I return this rifle and get a better one? If so, which one?
Looking for something that will last a long time with good care and be accurate in case I had to rely on it for food in a worst case scenario.
While it could be defective, I really doubt it. Likely what you are dealing with is the learning curve in shooting a powerful spring air rifle. There is a learning process, and it is not easy. I would say shooting a spring rifle is about the hardest thing you can do, and after you master that you will be a better shooter.
With the scope, first of all the kit scopes are not the best in the world, and if you go with another scope be sure you get one that is rated for spring powered air guns....the scope could be letting you down.
This is the process I have done , rest it on a bag, rest the butt end of the rifle on another bag, get it steady. Touch the rifle as little as possible, let it jump around when it shoots....then after the shot, do your best to put the rifle on the bags in the EXACT SAME WAY as you did last time. If you move the bags the harmonics in the rifle will change and the shot will go in a different place.....if you get everything perfect you will know if the gun is the issue.
If you want a spring gun to start with get a low powered one for starters, somewhere in the 600-ish fps range. If you can't do this then be ready for a learning curve.
Someone else brought up pellets, this can make a huge....as in HUGE...difference in how the gun shoots. Even going from different head sizes can make a big difference. You are going to have to try different ammo. And going online is really the only way I know of to get ammo choice. go to straight shooters and get their sample pack, it is fantastic if you are just starting out and don't have a drawer full of different pellets. IMHO even the crosman pellets at walmart are not that fantastic....so that could be another issue.
All that said I doubt the gun is defective, as you get into this hobby if you keep going down this road, you will find there are a great many people that are very....lets say brand loyal, it makes chevy vs ford look like playground fights. These people are so biased they can't see past it and will bad mouth anything but their little brand....and nothing and I do mean NOTHING will change your mind.
Educate yourself on spring gun shooting, try different pellets, and I would bet you will get that gun shooting quarters at 25 yards in no time....it is just practice, like playing the guitar, you don't become ________ in a day....it takes lots of practice.
And be very suspicious of anyone suggesting something they have never even seen is defective and suggests you getting really mad about them not taking something back. There are many people on these boards that are very clueless at about everything, including laws.
Air rifles are firearms in a great many places and subject to the same laws, the retailer is likely very correct in saying they will not take it back and you need to send it back to Umerex for repair.