Hard to have a scope conversation without the discussion ending up on the top shelf offerings. I'd much rather hear about people's experience with the scopes they consider inferior, and what about it they didn't like. Might be people are talking smack on scopes they never owned based just on where it was made. Yeah- you can always got top shelf if you have and want to spend the money, but if you don't, you want to get the most for your limited dollars at a lower price point. Good luck having that convo on HERE without being made to feel like a jackass for not spending $2,000+ on a scope.
Anyway, from my experience in budget and mid-range scopes, a good scope at the 400 dollar mark is the Vortex Diamondback, if have $500 a very popular scope is the Hawke Sidewinder. Optisan has some good offering in this price range as well. I did not find anything in the Athlon line to be that impressive at these price points.