question about semi-jacketed slugs

i have shot these from my trapdoor powder guns with velocities below 1000fps
with excellent expansion and accuracy.
i'm just wondering what could i expect trying a 300gr semi jacketed hollow point
from my Hatsan Piledriver around 1000fps. i have read that jacketed bullets dont do well
from airgun platforms.
is it because the velocity that was available in the past from airguns ?
please, keep in mind...i will be sizing them correctly for my piledrivers bore.
thanks for any information on this subject. 👨‍🌾
 
i understand that, i have handloaded for over 40 years. i have substituted BP for
smokeless many years ago and use quickload for calculated pressure ratings.
what your saying is what i have read, but have also read (ammoguide) says thats a myth and
they work well in a airgun with the horsepower to perform.
i'm looking for an experienced input that has tried it.
thanks !
 
i understand that, i have handloaded for over 40 years. i have substituted BP for
smokeless many years ago and use quickload for calculated pressure ratings.
what your saying is what i have read, but have also read (ammoguide) says thats a myth and
they work well in a airgun with the horsepower to perform.
i'm looking for an experienced input that has tried it.
thanks !
No prob, that's why I said it's "my gut take on it". I personally don't think they will even get out of the barrel, especially at the lower pressure end of 3,000 PSI.

Curious about your results, I don't mind being proven wrong.
 
I've tried jacketed bullets and they do indeed get stuck but haven't tried them over 900 fps but I didn't size them either so maybe you will be ok
The thing I'm thinking about that is if you undersize them sufficiently to not get stuck, how well are they going to take the rifling? Really want to see some experimental data/targets vs standard soft lead.
 
Following...

Recent testing myself using .356, .357, .358 semi jacketed and solid copper.

I'm using a Lee bullet sizer in each cal mounted on my Redding T7.

Some slugs (Bullets) have a gas ring design some are smooth wall. Every one tested so far has had a significant loss of fps.

Example 1 (Baseline), 110gr .357 NSA slugs. OAL, .519
900 fps from a TJ 1:26 barrel at 190 bar

Example 2, 110gr .357 Zero Bullet mfg. OAL .476
680 fps from TJ 1:26 barrel at 190 bar

Pressed through sizing die and weighed. Each was a perfect test sample.

I suspect the gas ring on the Zero Bullet may be causing enough blowby to impede consistency for use in an air powered system.

Currently, I've had about a 50/50 ratio of slugs that have cleared the barrel and slugs they have jammed.

I am currently working with 2 different bullet manufactures trying to develop a consistent slug. The wheels on this bus turn really slow.... It's taken a lot of time and effort to persuade these folks to cross the tracks into the possibilities of the high power airgun world.

It's late/early and I've just finished fart'n around my dungeon machine shop. It's nearly Deer season here in Michigan and I'm burning the candle on both ends to keep my short list happy. 😊

If you're interested, I'll continue to post my findings. Or, I'll sit in the shadows and follow along.

FX Impact M3 .35 and Western Airguns Rattler .357 were used in testing outside the provide example data.

Perhaps a single shot, like a Texan would offer varying results due to its bolt design..

I'm going to make a bench mounted test rig this week. I need to locate a source to obtain barrels that are in current production and that are in use in the airgun world. I can easily make a barrel in my shop. But I'm thinking that's not a realistic choice as that's not what is common place. I've never made one. 😊 I'm thinking it can't be that difficult, should be easy. Then again, I thought my ex wife was easy too. I'm still paying for that one. 😁

Cheers!

K9
 
Last edited: