I know they aren't exactly the same models you asked about, but are close. I agree with above, my 4-12x40 utg works, but the reticle is thicker, mediocre glass and heavy. But, it holds zero on my Diana 36 and hasn't needed ANY adjustment in a couple thousand rounds/years. Does its job. I never use the illuminated reticle.
I have a Hawke Airmax 4-12x40 on another Diana 36. Thinner reticle, holds zero, clearer/brighter glass. Lighter weight. Also has needed no adjustments over thousands of rounds.
I like the Hawke so much, I bought another for my Marauder.
I did try buying a Hawke Airmax off ebay(new) from seller "focus camera". I sent it back as it had damaged threads at the optical bell where a sunshade would screw in and the AO adjuster had a ton of slop in it. Didn't even mount it. So, do buy from reputable sources.