Main thing is the diameter of the groove o-ring sits in. Doubt it is the o-ring thats the issue, it's likely that the grove is not machined to spec.
5.28+1.78 = 7.06mm
That's more than sufficient. Check the groove. Does the o-ring sit even all around in it? slide the probe in and out and check if it catches the o-ring and moves it out of place.