
This guy may have more experience testing .25 slugs than anybody on the forum. Wealth of info there, stoti!
While I greatly appreciate Stoti's contributions and admire him, it is not even close to the work a few here and elsewhere have been involved in. Most quietly. Here are a few.
Roach Creek who set a long distance record with slugs what, near 10 years ago at 615 yards. Tofazfou, (You can now find him on youtube is a Long Range King). Jack Haley that built the long range guns for Roach Creek years ago, (RIP). Doug Noble who has been building and shooting very long range for years, R.J. Porter, another blast from the past, and Myself., a student of Roach Creek in both testing, shooting long range and designing and casting for the same and have been testing slugs since what, 2007?
We have all learned the same thing. There were and are barrels out there that are absolutely lasers for slugs. Sadly, FX ignored all the info that was out there. Mostly due to a given tester that had NO Idea what it took and guided FX in a rather hunt and peck odyssey. Thankfully, regardless, it has led to the industry seriously starting to pay attention to slug shooting and FX is making a grand effort. Sadly, it is still a little misguided. What works somewhat well for their literally hollow slug as it can compress to match the bore and choke, no other slug does that. Soooooo, Here we are. Stoti hit the nail on the head, and pointed to a fact that different shooters are having differing results . Why?
Here are what we that are slug shooters have found over the years. First and for most, the same rules apply that have been the standard in lead slug shooting in firearms for centuries. It works exactly the same way. No need to re-invent the wheel here. I can tell you where to get a liner that is more accurate, same od. within a few thou. and dirt cheap with years of excellent performance under it's belt. (Later on this).
First, Twist is extremely important. Luckily, this has been set pretty much in stone long ago for our .22 slugs. 1-16 for 35-40 gr and 1-20 for 29 to 34 gr slugs. ease peezy. It matters not whether the slug is being propelled by powder or air. Same-Same.
Next, yes some find success with a choke, but darned rare. This is part of the differing results across the forums with people shooting slugs. Particularly FX AG's .Research choke bbl's in .22 fire arms. Other than a few odd ones, or a tapered bore or two, they don't exist. Why, they only work in poor bbl's to fix issues. Not in precision bbl's.
And lastly, every one by virtue of manufacturing difficulty in inventory and complications, has to order by the Thou., and hope it works. It does Some Times, but not regularly. . This is where "BLIND HOG Finds Acorn" part comes in.
Best accuracy most often is found from .0001 under groove dia. the .0003 over. This is the most important thing to know and understand in slug accuracy in AG's, and loose the Choke! the FX choke is a monster. Most acceptable chokes for pellets range from .0005 to .0051. the FX choke in the Superior Heavy is .005+. HUGE. It may work well often with their Hybrid, but very spotty for any other brand which is a solid core projectile. (One would think the .000 under would hurt performance by allowing pressure past the projectile, however the lessenig of friction far out weighs any loss. Gains of up to 35 fps have been seen).
I rec'd an FX Superior Heavy before the public did for testing. The results were terrible until I removed the choke. I lapped, polished the bore, re-crowned the muzzle and it is now ultra accurate. I have no issue with it. If only they would listen to a few of us who have been doing this for a long time rather than an energetic newbie. I admire his enthusiasm, but he isn't quite there yet in practical knowledge.
Now for the best part! Brownell's Gunsmithing Supply has the barrels we need in .223, Not the .218 that the FX is listed as, but in truth is a Real .22 cal. rather than the actual .214+ the FX offering is after the slug leaves the choke. Tons more slugs available for it, and get this, Ultra find finish in the bore and all for 39 Bucks USD. Yep, 39 bucks, and available for both light slugs at 1-20 twist and heavy with the 1-16 offering.
Here are a few pics of what the FX Superior Heavy shot like both before the choke removal and after. and the link to the bbl's at Brownell's.
Added Bonus, as the base of the the slug is larger in dia. from the Brownell's liner than the FX, it is a bit faster with less air pressure as well. Not much, but every bit counts! And ---It fits the same sleeve the FX Liner does. Woo-Hoo!!!
Brownell's link:
https://www.brownells.com/gunsmith-tools-supplies/barrel-tools/barrel-liners/22-caliber-rimfire-barrel-liners-prod10974.aspx Before and after choke removal.
At only 50 yards. Now after the work at 80 yards, 1 shot to settle the Reg. and 10 on target.
How about 60 shots at 80 yards to check for consistency?
This is what happens when you remove the choke, and a bonus is far less leading!
My writings and test can be found over at the GTA with well over 8000 post and the old tag with way more post.
One last rambling. The slug suppliers cannot provide every size in .0001" so it is up to the shooter to do it. Size to your barrel. Slug it, and size accordingly. Test all four sized. from .0001 under to .0003 over. Work? yep. Too much trouble? That is what pellets are for. Sizers are cheap from NOE Mold services. And have fun as it can be very rewarding in the end!
Knife
https://www.youtube.com/user/tofazfou