High Penetration ammo for .25?

25-cal-1_orig.jpg




22 cal to 375 cal & Balls - www.mrhollowpoint.com
 
1. The quarry is for a pest control operation to remove Muscovy ducks - trapping failed and so we have permits to use air guns. it is completely legal, to the point the Sheriff’s deputy was spectating and saying “nice shot.” I know ducks can be a touchy subject.



Hey Jonny,

hope your hunt went well! I really enjoyed your projectile requirements and quarry description ("more pokey pokey stabby power" and "turbo-waddle" really communicated well). 👍



Maybe I hunt in a different part of the world, but could you help me understand how hunting ducks is a "touchy subject"?

Happy hunting! 😊

Matthias





 
I am astounded that I never noticed that ALL slugs other than the big bores are hollow points? (don't have a good small caliber slug gun myself, all pellets so far)

Considering how many (perhaps most?) are using slugs for long range targets, paper and steel,,. it boggles the mind! How much more accuracy and range would one be able to eek out of their slug rig with a proper spitzer tip?

As this thread indicates, even for hunting, in some applications you want more penetration than expansion, or even an exit wound.
 
@JungleShooter

Here in the States there are federal laws that dictate weapon and projectile type for waterfowl. Specifically shotguns with non toxic shot for migratory waterfowl are required. No rifles, no airguns, no lead. Muscovy ducks are non migratory waterfowl that those federal laws would not apply to but many don't/can't tell the difference.
 


Hey Jonny,

hope your hunt went well! I really enjoyed your projectile requirements and quarry description ("more pokey pokey stabby power" and "turbo-waddle" really communicated well).
1f44d.svg




Maybe I hunt in a different part of the world, but could you help me understand how hunting ducks is a "touchy subject"?

Happy hunting!
1f60a.svg


Matthias





Hi Mattias,

It’s for all the things Hal4son mentioned, and a few other factors.



1. Muscovy ducks are common in public parks, particularly ones with ponds. Calling them “non-migratory” is an understatement - it seems they never leave the pond they choose to live in. So here in Texas, they’re a common park animal, they grow comfortable around people, kids feed them, etc. Some people keep them as “pets” while others raise them as livestock.

2. Going to a suburban neighborhood at night with a rifle to shoot all their ducks is - for obvious reasons - a situation with real potential to get out of hand. Shooting a tuned-up PCP rifle in very close proximity to homes is risky enough as it is, let alone if someone looks out the window to see someone with a rifle and flashlight gunning down the ducks in their pond. It is not the type of operation that gets clearance by local governing authorities very often. Rightfully so, because we still had to deal with a few idiots who wanted to observe too closely. I’m truly surprised no idiots walked in front my rifle like “hiiii what ya doin???”

It’s a whole other world when you’re shooting next to people’s houses. Shot placement counts, and people get curious, and to top it off, for all the reasons Hal mentioned, they are quick to call police and report a shooter and/or the fact it’s ducks.


 
I am astounded that I never noticed that ALL slugs other than the big bores are hollow points? (don't have a good small caliber slug gun myself, all pellets so far)

Considering how many (perhaps most?) are using slugs for long range targets, paper and steel,,. it boggles the mind! How much more accuracy and range would one be able to eek out of their slug rig with a proper spitzer tip?

As this thread indicates, even for hunting, in some applications you want more penetration than expansion, or even an exit wound.

I think the majority of the slug market probably belongs to people who hunt / cull, and that higher BC and accuracy is worth the money to get better terminal ballistics at long ranges.

I know I can see a night and day difference between pellets and slugs when shooting pests, and I’m rarely more than 15-20 yards away. That’s why I use slugs - they seem to yield a more humane result.
 
Going to a suburban neighborhood at night with a rifle to shoot all their ducks.



It’s a whole other world when you’re shooting next to people’s houses. 

We still had to deal with a few idiots who wanted to observe too closely. I’m truly surprised no idiots walked in front my rifle like “hiiii what ya doin???”



Someone looks out the window to see someone with a rifle and flashlight GUNNING DOWN THE DUCKS IN THEIR POND

It is not the type of operation that gets clearance by local governing authorities very often.






Jonny,

I read your post several times — you produced a wide grin on my face. 😊 Very funny. Worth quoting again....!

Thanks! 👍🏼

Matthias



PS: Sign my up for your next duck shoot. I'll provide the ammo and pizza.
 
Lots of good responses!



1. The quarry is for a pest control operation to remove Muscovy ducks - trapping failed and so we have permits to use air guns. it is completely legal, to the point the Sheriff’s deputy was spectating and saying “nice shot.” I know ducks can be a touchy subject. Tonight is operation #3, and will likely be the last op.

2. Muscovy ducks are the M1 Abrams of ducks. The reality of the operation is we dont get sufficient chance for head shots, as once the first duck goes down, the rest start to “turbo waddle” and looking all around. So that leaves body shots.

3. It’s difficult to hit the heart from the majority of angles because they are THICK with feathers and bones. Most of the shots had to come from the side. They have VERY thick feathers, and so to get at the heart means penetrating a thick plumage, a wing, sometimes wing bones, then more plumage between the wing and body, then a lot of bones, and Muscovies have some pretty hefty skeletons.



4. As far as I know, nothing like a “pointed slug” exists. I did fare well with pointed Eun Jins, NSA 55-grain slugs, H&N Barracuda Hunter Extreme, and JSB Exact King Heavy. I got the best penetration from NSA 55gr, but they’re tough to cram into the breach. Eun Jin penetrated well when it actually flew straight. JSB was kinda in the middle, but i didn’t use it much, in favor of heavier ammo.



5. Did not fare well with lighter ammo. My go-to is NSA 26.8gr and it was on the light side of penetration. Polymags won’t penetrate like I need them to - too many layers of feather, meat, and bone will open up their expansion.



Final thoughts:

If there’s a non-lead alloy pointed ammo that is also heavy - perhaps even domed - I think that would be close to what I would need.





The NSA ammo isn't too big. The alloy blend that Nick needs to use for successful automation in manufacturing lends the slugs to being harder than his competitors. This makes it difficult to seat them in the breech sometimes. I'm assuming the Armada utilizes a Lothar-Walther barrel with a twist rate of 1:17.7 . This has proven to be a good barrel for pellets, but with the slower twist and the choke, it's very difficult to find a slug it likes. After hearing your story, I think the Predator Polymags or the H&N Hornets are the best tool for the job. They're not a super long range pellet, but the nossler tips provide deep penetration and the soft lead provides excellent expansion after penetrating.
 
I'm assuming the Armada utilizes a Lothar-Walther barrel with a twist rate of 1:17.7 . This has proven to be a good barrel for pellets, but with the slower twist and the choke, it's very difficult to find a slug it likes.



Not sure if it’s LW or Green Mountain. The rifling has 10 lands and grooves, and that’s about all I can tell.
 
I am astounded that I never noticed that ALL slugs other than the big bores are hollow points? (don't have a good small caliber slug gun myself, all pellets so far)

Considering how many (perhaps most?) are using slugs for long range targets, paper and steel,,. it boggles the mind! How much more accuracy and range would one be able to eek out of their slug rig with a proper spitzer tip?

As this thread indicates, even for hunting, in some applications you want more penetration than expansion, or even an exit wound.



There are a few aerodynamic reasons for this as I understand it. First is that for slugs and bullets, blunt nose or hollowpoint designs are the best shape at subsonic velocities. The second is that moving weight bias to the rear helps with stability. Combining those two together makes hollowpoints a logical choice.

This was a fun read and thought experiment since all the heaviest projectiles are hollowpoints (slugs). I like the Benjamin dome and Baracuda options.