Help a noob find an air rifle

New to the site, pretty new to airguns.

I have a Winchester 1977XS multi pump air rifle I got awhile back to plink with the kids. At 50ft (yes FEET, lol), it's putting 5 shot groups of about 1.5 inches. I realize this is a 50 dollar rifle and the Crosman Premier pellets I'm using aren't match grade, but I want better accuracy than this.

So, I'm searching for a new rifle. This is where I could use some help. The world of air rifles has changed and I don't know quality from crap.

My criteria:

- $300 to $400 is my price range. Would love a PCP, but I can't spend the money for a compressor, etc right now. The Seneca Aspen would be perfect if it were high quality, but the pump seems to fail too often according to reviews.

- Accuracy is key. I plan to have a good scope on whatever I buy and will use this for squirrels and target shooting out to 30-40 yards. School me on realistic expectations. Can I get half inch groups at that distance in my price range?

- Would prefer something that takes a magazine and I don't have to load one pellet at a time into the breech.

- Would prefer .22 cal.

- Is "low maintenance" a thing, or will I be replacing seals, etc on pretty much any rifle I get? If maintenance is inevitable, I'd prefer it to be an easy rifle to work on.

- Format? PCP is out because of cost. Multipumps seem to be the "cheap stuff" and unlikely to give the accuracy I want. Springers and gas piston seem to have recoil. Does the recoil make them less accurate? Do break barrels suffer from barrel droop over time -- or from not locking closed tightly enough to keep the same point of impact consistently?

- Would prefer something with a suppressor built into the barrel to keep it backyard friendly. I will be shooting it 90% of the time on my property on a 25 yd range.

I'm leaning towards a fixed barrel underlever cocking rifle because of my price range and the concerns I have about other designs. Would appreciate any input or suggestions, especially if my concerns (like break barrels eventually having droop or losing accuracy over time) are unfounded.
 
Maybe drop down to a hw30 for your price range. It will last you your whole life

All of the HW's look excellent. They also all exceed my price range or lack quite a few of the things I am looking for. Is this a case of placing accuracy or quality above most of the rest of my "want list" features?

I guess if I had to rank the features in order of importance to me, they would be:

1. Accuracy

2. Quiet / suppressed

3. Price point

4. Everything else...
 
I have a lot of nice air rifles which far exceed your price range.

OTOH I just recently spent the first quality time with my Hatsan Hydra after having purchased the rifle a few of months ago. And it really did the job!

Squirrels to 30-40 yards? Especially with JSB Hades pellets I would say that it has both the accuracy and power you would need. 

Multi-shot with magazine - check.

Pretty backyard friendly with built-in silencer - check.

Really nice and easily adjustable trigger.

The Hydra's air cylinder is not too large and is of lower working pressure (200 bar/2,900 psi), so it would definitely be feasible to use a hand pump with this PCP gun. Maybe not enjoyable, but feasible. And in .22 mine gets 30-40 or so shots between fills without POI change out to 25 yards.

Just a thought - you could own a PCP and enjoy the much easier accuracy that such a gun affords over a springer.
 
I have a lot of nice air rifles which far exceed your price range.

OTOH I just recently spent the first quality time with my Hatsan Hydra after having purchased the rifle a few of months ago. And it really did the job!

Squirrels to 30-40 yards? Especially with JSB Hades pellets I would say that it has both the accuracy and power you would need. 

Multi-shot with magazine - check.

Pretty backyard friendly with built-in silencer - check.

Really nice and easily adjustable trigger.

The Hydra's air cylinder is not too large and is of lower working pressure (200 bar/2,900 psi), so it would definitely be feasible to use a hand pump with this PCP gun. Maybe not enjoyable, but feasible. And in .22 mine gets 30-40 or so shots between fills without POI change out to 25 yards.

Just a thought - you could own a PCP and enjoy the much easier accuracy that such a gun affords over a springer.

That's a good looking option. It's about 400 bucks before adding a scope or pump though. I'll keep it in mind, but I'm going to keep looking...
 
The hunter model of the Maximus is threaded for a mod, and is a 1/2" gun @30yds all day long with quality pellets. Mine is good with 13.43 gr. JSB pellets. it is a 2000 psi gun, easy to pump and easy on hand pumps at that lower operating pressure. The Beeman QB Chief is also 2000 psi, needs a mod (back yard friendly with a TKO mod), and has a well deserved reputation for accuracy. Favorite for the QB is 15.89 JSB. Both of these rifles were well under $200 on sale and at that price, could have a pump, mod, and rifle under $350 with judicious shopping. Both of them leaked from the foster fill connector, easily replaced, and no leaks since.
 
There are two choices. 

One: The Beeman R9. Very accurate, Will last forever. This is a springer. 

Two: The Gamo Urban is fantastic. Light, easy to point, reliable, extremely accurate, and very pump friendly due to its small air tank. You will get on average 30 shots per fill. However even the cheap 50 dollar Walmart pump works fine on this one. 

Cheers

Kit
 
The recoil of a springer definitely affects accuracy. More power = more recoil. My good break barrels hold point of impact, but I think it's more a matter of which guns do, and which guns don't rather than springers vs. PCP or something else. I bought a Gamo Extreme Hunter (IIRC the name) and it recoils so much that I can't get it to group under any circumstances. My Mendoza built Crosman groups pretty nicely. None of them get much action since I made the jump to PCP. PCP is a rabbit-hole that will cost you a small fortune if you get the bug.

GsT
 
The recoil of a springer definitely affects accuracy. More power = more recoil. My good break barrels hold point of impact, but I think it's more a matter of which guns do, and which guns don't rather than springers vs. PCP or something else. I bought a Gamo Extreme Hunter (IIRC the name) and it recoils so much that I can't get it to group under any circumstances. My Mendoza built Crosman groups pretty nicely. None of them get much action since I made the jump to PCP. PCP is a rabbit-hole that will cost you a small fortune if you get the bug.

GsT

This is what I thought since the piston has to drive forward to produce the pressure to even begin moving the pellet. Hmm...

Yeah, pretty sure I already have the PCP bug...

I think I'll focus on PCP and just plan on getting a hand pump. Maybe I can save my money for a decent compressor later.

Thanks for all the replies so far! You guys are awesome and this has been really helpful.
 
GAMO Urban at Walmart for like 299.If your near a Cabelas or Bass pro they will match and they have them in store sometimes.When I got my Urban a couple years ago it was 399 at Cabelas and Walmart had it on rollback for 232 and they matched it in store didn’t have to order and wait. + it had air in it☺️

Nice find on that lower price at Wal-Mart! If I decide to go that route, I'll try to get Cabela's to price match.