What you are describing doesn't sound like creep.
Creep is where the reg consistently returns to the same pressure after each shot, but if you let it sit for an hour and come back, the pressure is higher.
Set point shift is where over many shooting sessions, the pressure the regulator returns to is higher than when you set it previously.
Your problem sounds like plain old inconsistency and I second the recommendation to rebuild the reg. You might not even have to replace any orings, just clean and relube everything with good silicone lube. Polishing can also help, both any sliding and sealing surfaces. I had good luck with the polishing outlined in the following video from Ernest, and the 3M polishing cloth he uses is awesome. I started with a much less aggressive grit than he did in the video, probably in the 2000-4000grit range.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p-p-sGTJCiA&t=1s