We all have preferences — and sometimes they are
logical — and sometimes
not so much.
Gridded reticles are no different.

If I
dial for elevation — I don't need a Christmas tree and the 80 ornaments hanging from it.

If I
hold for elevation, but usually shoot in calm conditions — I don't need an evergreen reticle either.

If I do a lot of
scopecam filming — I wouldn't want the clutter dots, I want a clean scope image.

If I do
rushed shooting (stalk hunting, or very mobile quarry) — holding for wind
and elevation is harder — so using the Christmas tree reticle will require a lot of practice. Dialing allows me to put the crosshairs dead center and squeeze the trigger.

Of course,
the solution are electronic reticles, where we cycle through a dozen options and select which reticle is most suitable for the shooting scenario we're facing.
It probably won't be long until those become common and affordable....
What a great time to be an airgunner!
Matthias