Why Picatinny

Caliber 22

Member
Nov 29, 2023
545
469
SA
I see this with air rifles as well as PB rifles. Why do people insist on using picatinny rails. Even if a rifle is equipped with dovetail, they will install a dovetail to picatinny adaptor just to use the picatinny. All the years I use whatever is on the rifle as it come from the factory, if any, and never had a problem. Some say it is better for recoil movement, but the adaptor is set on the dovetail anyway. Others say it is for replacing it on the same position after removing it. That you can do with dovetail as well. Anyway, once I installed the scope I don't have a reason to remove it often. For me one is not better than the other, it is just different. I am just curious what other people think about this.
 
I don't think it is the industry standard as dovetail is widely used as well, on air rifles as well as PB rifles. I cannot say if there is a wider range available or not but even then, why do you prefer it? Just because of the 2 explanations above? Just asking.
Other reasons I prefer picatinny are:

1. It's more secure, although for a PCP, it's not as important unless you're banging it around in the woods or PRS/NRL22 competitions.

2. Again, there's a wider selection. For me personally, I take an overkill approach when it comes to airguns. Scopes are getting bigger and heavier. Quality scopes rings in picatinny are available in 34mm, 36mm, and even 40mm main tube sizes. Not so much options in those sizes are available for dovetail.

3. There's also scopes, thermal, and night vision optics with integral mounts that are available in picatinny vs dovetail. Also, many red dot optics, holographic sights, magnifier mounts have mounting bases for picatinny only.

4. If you really want high quality scopes rings, you'll mostly find them available in picatinny only.

5. Indexing. If you decide to do maintenance on your airguns, removing the scope is something you might have to do. When installing it back on, having the available slots with picatinny is much more precise.

6. Switching between optics with picatinny QD mounts is easier and precise. With my Leshiy 2, I switch between a magnified optic and a red dot with return-to-zero picatinny QD mounts.

There might be a few more advantages with picatinny that I might be forgetting but this post is getting long. Yes, dovetail looks cleaner but I'm an overkill kind of person. Hope this clears it up on my preference.
 
Here's a thread that was posted recently with some of the issues the OP was having.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Airgun Al
Here's a thread that was posted recently with some of the issues the OP was having.

Yep!
That was me!
 
The problem with the 11mm dovetail, is it really limits your scope ring options!

If you fall in love with the popular Arken SH4 scope, (or any scope) with a 34mm tube, and attempted to mount it on a rifle with a 11mm dovetail, you will quickly realize that your scope ring options are limited.

VERY LIMITED.

I found only 3 sets of normal scope rings that would accomplish this, without useing adapters, or a cantilever style mount.

My only 3 options were:

Unbranded scope rings from china ( Inexpensive. I ordered a set about 3 weeks ago, and still have not received them)....
1 set from WestHunter that utilize a plastic spacers for 30mm and 1" scopes (Inexpensive, but I was not fond of the spacer design)
1 set of $50 rings from X-Accu which I ordered yesterday, and should have soon.

Thats the problem with the 11mm dovetail, is it really limits your scope ring options!

If not for X-Accu offering these scope rings, the other options were sketchy no-name brand rings, cantilever scope mount, or adapters which add to scope height and complex the process.
 
The problem with the 11mm dovetail, is it really limits your scope ring options!

If you fall in love with the popular Arken SH4 scope, (or any scope) with a 34mm tube, and attempted to mount it on a rifle with a 11mm dovetail, you will quickly realize that your scope ring options are limited.

VERY LIMITED.


What is special about that scope?
 
I have two airguns and five powderburners. One of my airguns has dovetail (Crosman P1322), one of my powderburners has no rail at all, just holes for scope rings, and everything else has picatinny. Similarly, a lot of my optics only come with picatinny mounts -- they are manufactured without options for any other kind of mount. Some have the ability to switch, but it would be expensive.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Airgun Al
I'm a fan of the Weaver system which is the grandfather of the the "pictinny" that was just ripped off. They only difference is spacing was standardized, same rings. It is quite a secure system And I prefer it over dovetail. I find it really funny that 30-40 years ago everybody looked at the Weaver style as cheap and the Redfield style as the best.