I really hate it when results are wishy-washy. Those guys are shooting the lighter slugs, and Matt leans toward the lighter end as well, but anything under 27gr is completely unstable in my barrel. With 21gr, I can literally have flyers that are 2ft off at 70 yds. You can hear them tumbling when you shoot them. I'd say 2 out of 10 are completely unstable, and for the others the group size is 6" or more at 70 yds. Stupid things caused me to shoot my old chrono TWICE. I had it at the target comparing the readings to the LabRadar.
I would also question the desire to shoot the lighter slugs. The BC is much higher on the heavier slugs, and isn't that the point of shooting slugs? The problem really is having enough power to shoot them with authority, since the other advantage is not having to shoot slow. Of course I'm convinced that there are some myths with diabolo pellets as well. Ernest turned me on to shooting the 18gr JSBs over 1000 fps. They are more accurate than any of the slugs have been, BUT I haven't done that same test with a lot of wind. I think the situation will change in those conditions. With the latest power mods, I'm sure I can shoot the 18gr pellets well over supersonic, which might be fun to try.
I'll be glad to see more of the slug barrels get out, so we can compare notes. I hope this isn't one of those "find what your particular barrel likes" situations, but I'm starting to fear that it might be.
Rusty