if you want to be gentle get some paste and do it that way instead. they are specialized productsfor that. or: sounds crazy but tooth paste has Al2O3 in it in very very fine powder form thats what cleanes the tooth not the flavour they mix it with... it is obviously readily available
corundum is the third on the Mohs scale of hardness. 1. diamond, the somehing else 3. Al2O3.
or you can try red rouge jewellers rouge in powder form and mix it with water to form
a paste, but that will paint everythting like a pigment.
to get the idea:
steel is hardness 5
titanium 6
al2o3 is 9. diamond 10
i use corund powder at work for cleaning stuff, did try jewellers rouge but its messy business. toothpaste may be too fine, but at least you dont do any major damage it just takes longer