After using it for a month, the clarity on the Athlon Ares ETR 15-60 starts going away after about 45 power with my eyes.
I was going to reply earlier, but saw this post was a little older and you already made a purchase. But because you might not be perfectly happy…
The best advice I can give is… ”Don’t think you are going to find the perfect scope on the first try”, especially when asking others for their favorite.
Our eyes are different and there are going to be things you prefer that others don’t. Like I told the other guy, buy and sell and try many. You had some good examples from people that I have liked and hated (every expensive options).
I would start with the reticle. People too often overlook that most important aspect. Make sure you like the reticle layout and look at the thickness. I can’t stand a fine reticle and others wouldn’t haven’t anything else. Some scopes favor contrast and other resolution. Some seem really bright/blue and others more neutral.
Don’t be afraid to try cheaper scopes too, especially if you don’t dial elevation.
The Sightron SIII was a good pick for a long time because of the price. They aren’t as cheap as they used to be. They aren’t amazing, but they are still very good if you like the reticle options. The IV is just a bigger version, and the IVED adds better glass. The focus on the IV is pretty cool.
The Vortex GE is a really good scope, better glass than an SIII, and was a better deal back in the day before price hikes as well. Reticle choices are very limited.
Delta/Trijicon are about the same and are nice if you like the reticles and weight. I didn’t like the reticles, as they were much too fine on the Delta.
Athlons, I’m a big fan of the company but haven’t tried the high mag scope because the fine reticle turns me off big time.
NF - I haven’t tried the Comp, but only FFP versions. Loved the ATACR, but not for the price. Again, make sure you like the reticle options, and confirm they focus close enough for your uses, as many don’t focus close.
S&B was a good scope, but didn’t think it was worth the money.
March, still haven’t tried, but only because the right deal never came up when I was looking.
Kahles - My favorite scope ever. Not all agree here, but the optical formula for my eyes is amazing! Loved the reticle size and what it gave me. Amazing in low light where most of my shots are, and was amazing quality. Only really expensive scope that I thought was worth it. I have seen others try it and say they don’t like it. It isn’t as “bright” as some like.
Anyway, only you will know what is perfect for you.